What you can do to stop climate change
October 9, 2019
In the wake of the climate strike, it’s obvious that Americans are worried about climate change. We know our culture is doing something wrong, but we brush the guilt off of ourselves and onto corporations. This is an act of indifference: the deflection of moral burden is completely invalid. We should be actively trying all we reasonably can, and part of this is personal change. Being even slightly realistic shows us we need to do more.
The issue is not awareness; it’s a lack of appropriate willingness to act. In a culture that antagonizes corporations and institutions, we forget that we, Americans, are the ones with the moral prerogative to change our own practices. Corporations literally must follow, as they only exist as a product of our demand. Apathy is a privilege stemming from our deeper privilege of choice. This is one we must not forget to exercise.
I say this because the single most impactful thing people can do to mitigate their negative impacts on the environment, according to a study published by the University of Oxford, is to stop buying animal products. Americans are extremely hesitant to make the switch. Immediately, excuses are prompted, usually regarding health, expense or inconvenience.
Two of the most well-known and well-respected health organizations in the world (the American and British Dietetic Associations) state that a diet free of these products is healthy at all stages of life. Given the state of chronic health issues in America, eating a plant-based diet is likely the best thing we can do to mitigate health problems as well.
The truth is, and I speak from experience, veganism is only more expensive when buying fancy animal product replacements. Expense, in the case of middle and upper-class Americans, is used as an excuse for those with more complicated reservations. These reservations are often simply reluctance to change, which is no excuse. Privilege to do wrong does in no way make it right.
If you believe in climate change, you must also believe that a vegan diet is healthy and literally the most impactful thing we can feasibly do: the science equally proves each of these facts.
For those of us who choose what we eat, the switch is as easy as a different choice at the grocery store or on the menu. That is the extent of the choice that the Oxford study said is the most impactful thing we can do for the climate. It is absurdly simple. What is holding us back is fear of change: an atrociously ironic inhibitor. The longer we postpone legitimate change, the more horrific the change is going to be.
Individuals can fool themselves into doing horrendous things by looking around and excusing actions because they are the norm. Normal is not equivalent to moral. It’s time for us to make the better choice.
Sean Gannon • Nov 15, 2019 at 11:49 am
Good response, Gavin. That comment was a wild misrepresentation of your argument.
Gavin • Oct 24, 2019 at 2:22 pm
Jonathan,
This is surely true. There is a minority of people which can only thrive with a diet including animal products. This is, though, a minority. And it should not function as an excuse for the general public. Research shows a plant based diet can do wonders for a multitude of chronic illnesses, and sometimes people are quick to dismiss it it *might* not work. Experimentation is often necessary, because yes, no diet is completely right for everyone. Some are certainly generally better, though.
Thanks for your comment!
Gavin
Jonathan • Oct 23, 2019 at 2:27 pm
Gavin good points, but I do agree that certain dietary restrictions (allergen and chronic illness) require certain foods that may not be accessible under a solely vegan diet. I can provide a multitude of research to support this as well if you would like.
Gavin Victor • Oct 20, 2019 at 5:40 pm
Hi Allison,
I’d love to respond to your criticism of my article. Due to word count limits on my article, I simply can’t address everything, but here I can. I feel your response does real injustice to my point, and I’d like to clear the air. I’ll rebut point by point.
1) I never said this was the one and only thing we should do. It is, according to an extremely comprehensive study, the single most impactful thing a human can reasonably do. You are largely mischaracterizing my point.
2) Sure, dismantling some institutions would be great. But how can I, a student, dismantle the Army? Is that really feasible? Veganism is something just about everyone can do, even while simultaneously working on other aspects of the solution, like formal societal change. Also, look at the statistics, animal agriculture might be more of a problem than you think. I’d love to have a more in-depth conversation about this… if you admit that animal agriculture is bad (which it is in more ways than one), then you have a moral obligation to transition away from it.
3) Health: I presented the stat. It, factually, is healthy. Please don’t criticize my articles based off things I disprove with evidence! If you aren’t convinced, I can provide more specific studies. Also, I am a vegan athlete. Not protein deficient. There are tons of us.
4) Never did I say “everyone at Whitman going vegan would reverse climate change.” That’s obviously not the case. It is just the best thing we all can do. You are presenting a straw-man rebuttal as an excuse not to change.
5) At Whitman, on the meal plan, it’s cheaper to eat vegan. I can tell you from experience that it is absolutely financially viable when you purchase whole foods like vegetables, fruits, grains, etc.. Lentils are a lot cheaper than a steak, and most of us don’t live in “food deserts”. It is cheaper to eat vegan on the meal plan for the simple reason that vegan food is less expensive for Bon-Ap to buy.
6) Read about chronic illness and animal products. There is absolutely a correlation. Processed meat is classified as a carcinogen. Look at the health problems Americans have, look at their diet, and then look at the diet of places that don’t have these crises. If you look into it, you will see.
7) A close family member died of a heart attack. Yes I’m acquainted with chronic illness. Veganism really helped my chronic migraines. Vegans almost never get heart attacks. Simple logic. On and on, look into it: there is an amazing correlation between animal products and chronic illness.
8) I think you think my article is pretentious because I’m right, but you don’t want to accept it. Tons of your points are addressed in my article, but you failed to actually hear them.
9) I am literally in touch with the facts. I used stats and studies. I’m in touch socially, too: we need to use our privilege that is our food choices to help those who can’t.
Would it not be better if everyone approached things with an open mind? I approached the subject with one, and it convinced me. It is really easy to reject inconvenient truths. I was there, but I educated myself and found my position. I really encourage you to do the same.
Thank you for participating in the conversation, I’m happy when anyone wants to talk. I believe you want to find what is true and right, but you are approaching an opposing POV with lots of baggage. I urge you to look into the facts before approaching disagreeing viewpoints with disrespect and resentment.
If you or anyone else has further disagreements, I’d love to hear them. I want the truth, and I am open to hearing opposing POVs with legitimate evidence.
Thanks for engaging,
Gavin
Allison • Oct 15, 2019 at 10:33 am
I dont even know where to begin. This is very silly and unrealistic. We cannot stop climate change simply by becoming vegans. We need to dismantle large corporations like BP and the US military to stop climate change. While this is difficult, it is not simply a way to push the guilt off of us: it is the simple truth. We need to stop supporting these institutions individually and societally. There is no reason to guilt people into giving up necessary sources of protein. Even if every single person at Whitman became a vegan it would not reverse climate change. It is also extremely difficult to be on a vegan diet for many for financial and health reasons – being vegan is not as easy as picking a different meal option. People with chronic health issues will not simply solve their problems by switching to a vegan diet. Have you even ever met a poor person or a person who is chronically ill or disabled? This article really misses the mark and is incredibly pretentious and out of touch.
Jay Jay • Oct 9, 2019 at 4:01 pm
I have home work about this and idk how to write it and what it is