Whitman news since 1896

Whitman Wire

Vol. CLIV, Issue 9
Whitman news since 1896

Whitman Wire

Whitman news since 1896

Whitman Wire

Book Review: ‘Proust and the Squid’ breaks down reading

It is a miracle humans can read. It is a miracle we are able to decode not only the symbols of our alphabets but also the meanings entrenched behind sounds, word combinations and sentences. “Proust and the Squid: The Story and Science of the Reading Brain,” written by Maryanne Wolf, gives ample evidence to support these facts.

Wolf starts her book with the statement, “We were never born to read.” As a student at a small liberal arts school, majoring in a social science, this is hard to grasp. All I do is read. Every day I get home from classes and activities and assess my reading load for the night. It is always daunting. How can it be that this thing that takes up so much of my time is not innate within me?
Wolf examines this exact question, beginning with the earliest known languages and writing systems. From the Sumerians and Egyptians, we gain our first case study in written language.   Wolf follows written language through time, examining the advent of alphabets as we now know them and assessing the importance of our knowledge of symbols.

It is not necessarily the history of the written word, however, that is most fascinating within this book. It is the examination of the human brain and the undeniable evidence that reading is a lot harder than we may think. Our reading brain is our left brain and, though the areas of the brain used to read different languages vary, the English reader uses four parts of the brain. Through a complex system of interactions within these four parts of our brain, we are able to decode the meaning of the written word.

It is not enough for us just to be able to identify what a word may say due to its letter combination. Much of what we must know in order to read effectively has only a little to do with letters and is tied much more closely into syntax, semantics and phonology. These factors are made easier to learn if children are read to as infants and toddlers, expanding their vocabularies and their understanding of how words work together to make complex ideas.

It is truly no wonder reading disabilities exist. It is a marvel that anyone can read at all, and Wolf takes time to examine the most commonly discussed reading disability: dyslexia. People with dyslexia are often more gifted in some left-brain activities than others, and some of the most talented people of the Common Era are known to have been dyslexic.

As a research scientist, Wolf identifies that she is not used to writing for the general public and this is evident at times throughout the book. However, it is impossible not to find interest even within the scientific rhetoric, and it is only so ironic that in order to ascertain the information from this book, one must read.

View Comments (1)
More to Discover

Comments (1)

All Whitman Wire Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • A

    Allan WikmanMay 8, 2009 at 10:45 am

    Haven’t read the book. Just ordered from library. Eager to read because, already, I find discrepancies. Until age 32, the act so painful, so arduous, so plodding, I fought tooth and nail the need to read. Now,at 77, have become a student/expert on the etiology, symptoms, supposed varieties. But, moreso, widespread missunderstanding. For example: one of the worst things parents can do is to teach their child the alphabet BEFORE s/he learns to read! Why? “Reading” is the child of “speaking.” Meaning? Speech is made up of sounds (phonemes)which have NO RELATION to sounds of our ABCs. English phonemes contain EVERY SPEECH SOUND. Learning to read basics, then, is learning to match pronemes with their “brother” or “sister” letter combinations. The abiding fact is that speech came FIRST, then READING.

    I didn’t become a voracious reader until my infasnt son’s pediatrician/allegist adventitiously heard my raspy voice and ordered me to make an appointment to be tested. I was 32.

    I BELIEVE that, one reason I cannot read any faster (with comprehension) than I SPEAK (125-150 wpm), is that I passed the “learning end point, ” EIGHTH GRADE without gaining the skill. This, according to at least one expert.

    I think Ms. Pysno is “right on” where, in paragraph five, she zeros in on certain characteristics of language as being at the causal center of reading disabilities.

    Especially “syntax.” The more convolute, professorial, academic the writing, the quicker I give up on text…UNLESS…the subject for me is a MUST READ.

    How do I know I have a reading difficulty and am not simply seeking empathy? Following an extrance exam administered to me by the prep school I attended one year, the school told my parents, “We’ll accept him, but he must REPEAT ninth grade and take our ‘remedial’ reading’ program.

    I did both, the latter with absolutely no improvement.

    Allan Wikman
    Kingston, UlsterCountyUSA

    However, she seems, as so many, to not understand that the word, “dyslexia” is simply a Greek word which means, “difficulty reading.” ANY difficulty.

    Reply